NP53. Bodies of Thought: Science, Religion and the Soul in the Early Enlightenment by Ann Thomson (Oxford 2008) is a treasure trove of information on a little-known aspect of the Enlightenment.
Some Ryle essay footnotes appear on this site, which is devoted to life after physics.
There is no claim of expertise with respect to the musings on this page. Never use my stuff for homework!
Saturday, May 30, 2020
Friday, May 29, 2020
Footnote hr39
Footnote hr39. In From Religion to Philosophy (Edward Arnold 1912), F.M. Cornford tells us of a formulation of such ideas among archaic Greeks:
Man in Homer has two souls. His eidolon or psyche escapes from his mouth at the moment of death; it is his recognisable shape, which may, for a time, revisit his survivors in dreams. It does not exist until the moment of death ; and it does not carry with it to the world of shades any of his vital force. This resides in the other soul (θυμός [=thymos]), whose visible vehicle is the blood ; and it is only by drinking blood that the eidolon can recover its 'wits ’ (φρένες [=phrenes]) or consciousness.
Footnote BV38
BV38. I tend to think of process as a word that covers a class of actualities. Process is also a word that covers a class of descriptions of the actualities, just as the word blueprint represents a whole array of distinct static designs or the term computer program covers a whole array of unique algorithms. In many cases, the word process implies a particular description which we may think of as having input values, an algorithm (or something like one) -- which is also a description -- and an output value.
That is to say, in many cases the word process stands for some complex set of motions, or changes, between time to and ta. Though the motions may be complex, the input and output values, when they are well defined, tend to fall within specified ranges. In any case, we need to distinguish between a description and the actuality that it is intended to represent. To say that any process is only composed of its moving particles or changing units is to make a category mistake, or, anyway, a mistake. Reduction into parts does not prevent a process description from representing an actual process.
So granting that when one says process, one is speaking a name for a class of actualities. Also, the general term process is not an entity itself (except in a "higher order" semantic sense). Now we may admit that any perceived object is a construction of the observing apparatus, which selects out of the environmental input those data sets that are recognized as useful (perhaps) information (in the Shannon sense). That is to say, whatever stream of information is "found" in the environment, is taken to represent an entity or actuality associated with that information. Hence, on that basis, the concepts of river and mind both represent actualities.
These days we realize that probably most changes in the mental process correspond to patterns of neuron firings. The question is whether there are any changes going on in some immaterial substance or presence or whether, as John Locke argued, matter can think if God so rules.
That is to say, in many cases the word process stands for some complex set of motions, or changes, between time to and ta. Though the motions may be complex, the input and output values, when they are well defined, tend to fall within specified ranges. In any case, we need to distinguish between a description and the actuality that it is intended to represent. To say that any process is only composed of its moving particles or changing units is to make a category mistake, or, anyway, a mistake. Reduction into parts does not prevent a process description from representing an actual process.
So granting that when one says process, one is speaking a name for a class of actualities. Also, the general term process is not an entity itself (except in a "higher order" semantic sense). Now we may admit that any perceived object is a construction of the observing apparatus, which selects out of the environmental input those data sets that are recognized as useful (perhaps) information (in the Shannon sense). That is to say, whatever stream of information is "found" in the environment, is taken to represent an entity or actuality associated with that information. Hence, on that basis, the concepts of river and mind both represent actualities.
These days we realize that probably most changes in the mental process correspond to patterns of neuron firings. The question is whether there are any changes going on in some immaterial substance or presence or whether, as John Locke argued, matter can think if God so rules.
Monday, May 25, 2020
Footnote gk63
gk63. Having made clear his position on reincarnation in his book Immortality, Paul Edwards goes on to ridicule the notion of resurrection as expressed in the philosopher John Hick's "cloud cuckoo land" fantasies. As an antidote, Edwards brings to bear The Future of an Illusion, a defense of atheism by Edwards's fellow Austrian, Sigmund Freud.
In James Strachey's English translation of Freud's Illusion, the quotation reads:
We may note that in his introduction to his anthology, Edwards -- who signed the atheistic Humanist Manifesto II -- goes to great lengths to test spiritual concepts on the basis of materialist or "scientific" concepts, but rarely if ever considers using a converse test -- not that it is very clear how one would go about making a converse test. Yet, it may be observed that for centuries materialistic concepts were indeed weighed in accord with a spiritual (or spiritualized) scale.
In other words, why should the truth of a claim only be provable by the currently accepted set of assumptions? What if we were to test modern "facts" by a different set of assumptions -- say those of Thomas Aquinas? Who is to say which set of assumptions is correct?
Despite his admiration for Russell, Edwards had, I would say, the engineering outlook so prevalent among 20th Century intellectuals. I don't mean that he was an engineer or could do mathematics; I mean that he saw the world as based on a nuts-and-bolts no-nonsense materialist machinery. Much of his output -- he wrote or edited 16 books -- was focused on skewering those whom he saw as obscure or unscientific. As far as I know, nothing he wrote is regarded as a major contribution to philosophy, which is not to say that his work was not worthwhile.
While no doubt there is value in exposing some claims of popular parapsychologists; was that endeavor worth all the attention he gave it? I suppose something can be said in favor of his analysis of the work of Martin Heidegger, Heidegger's Confusions (Prometheus 2004), but one wonders how Edwards could do anything but debunk Heidegger, given Edwards's materialism.
Please see the anthology Immortality edited by Paul Edwards (Prometheus 1997) and James Strachey's translation of The Future of an Illusion by Sigmund Freud (Norton 1962). Strachey based his translation on the translation of W.D. Robson-Scott, which was published in 1928 by Hogarth Press and the Institute for Psychoanalysis in London. Freud's book was first published as Zukunft einer Illusion (Internationaler Pyschoanalytischer Verlag. 1927).
For other footnoted information on Edwards, please see:
Footnote dh97
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-dh97.html
Footnote np54
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-np54.html
Footnote ds45
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-ds45.html
Footnote sf51
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-sf51.html
"What use to man is the illusion of a kingdom on the moon whose revenues have never yet been seen by anyone?" Let us leave the heavens (he then quotes his fellow skeptic Heinrich Heine) to the "angels and the sparrows."
In James Strachey's English translation of Freud's Illusion, the quotation reads:
Of what use to them is the mirage of wide acres in the moon, whose harvest no one has ever yet seen? As honest smallholders on this earth they will know how to cultivate their plot in such a way that it supports them. By withdrawing their expectations from the other world and concentrating all their liberated energies into their life on earth, they will probably succeed in achieving a state of things in which life will become tolerable for everyone and civilization no longer oppressive to anyone. Then, with one of our fellow- unbelievers, they will be able to say without regret:Strachey footnote:
Den Himmel uberlassen wir
Den Engeln und den Spatzen.
‘We leave Heaven to the angels and the sparrows.’ From Heine’s poem Deutschland (Caput I). The word which is here translated ‘fellow-unbelievers’ — in German ‘Unglaubensgenossen ’ — was applied by Heine himself to Spinoza...The words of Freud that Edwards omitted ring somewhat hollow in light of the atrocities and mass death of World War II, much of it instigated by people with little regard for heaven -- Nazis, communists and materialists of every sort, along with not-very-sincere churchmen.
We may note that in his introduction to his anthology, Edwards -- who signed the atheistic Humanist Manifesto II -- goes to great lengths to test spiritual concepts on the basis of materialist or "scientific" concepts, but rarely if ever considers using a converse test -- not that it is very clear how one would go about making a converse test. Yet, it may be observed that for centuries materialistic concepts were indeed weighed in accord with a spiritual (or spiritualized) scale.
In other words, why should the truth of a claim only be provable by the currently accepted set of assumptions? What if we were to test modern "facts" by a different set of assumptions -- say those of Thomas Aquinas? Who is to say which set of assumptions is correct?
Despite his admiration for Russell, Edwards had, I would say, the engineering outlook so prevalent among 20th Century intellectuals. I don't mean that he was an engineer or could do mathematics; I mean that he saw the world as based on a nuts-and-bolts no-nonsense materialist machinery. Much of his output -- he wrote or edited 16 books -- was focused on skewering those whom he saw as obscure or unscientific. As far as I know, nothing he wrote is regarded as a major contribution to philosophy, which is not to say that his work was not worthwhile.
While no doubt there is value in exposing some claims of popular parapsychologists; was that endeavor worth all the attention he gave it? I suppose something can be said in favor of his analysis of the work of Martin Heidegger, Heidegger's Confusions (Prometheus 2004), but one wonders how Edwards could do anything but debunk Heidegger, given Edwards's materialism.
Please see the anthology Immortality edited by Paul Edwards (Prometheus 1997) and James Strachey's translation of The Future of an Illusion by Sigmund Freud (Norton 1962). Strachey based his translation on the translation of W.D. Robson-Scott, which was published in 1928 by Hogarth Press and the Institute for Psychoanalysis in London. Freud's book was first published as Zukunft einer Illusion (Internationaler Pyschoanalytischer Verlag. 1927).
For other footnoted information on Edwards, please see:
Footnote dh97
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-dh97.html
Footnote np54
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-np54.html
Footnote ds45
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-ds45.html
Footnote sf51
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-sf51.html
Footnote sf51
sf51. With respect to life after death and the problem of retention of individuality, Paul Edwards observes
This note may be of interest:
Of course, if one thinks of an individual as a stream, one sees that quite some while may elapse before the stream merges into a river and the river into the ocean. In other words, Edwards does not account for an in-between possibility. Such a possibility is given in the occasional testimonies of people who have experienced the merger of one "soul" with another. That is, such a person reports that, at least for short periods, there is an inability to distinguish the self – in the sense of who I am – from the other person (usually a lover). Many take such accounts to be poetic or metaphorical. But, if we regard the existence of spirits as just as plausible as the existence of matter, then such a possibility need not be regarded as a simple illusion.
On Edwards and his 'messiah'
Edwards saw Wilhelm Reich, a fellow Austrian Jew who had also escaped the Nazis, as a very important man, saying that on his arrival in New York in 1947, the "talk of the town" was Wilhelm Reich and that for years he and his friends regarded Reich as "something akin to a messiah."
"There was ... a widespread feeling that Reich had an original and penetrating insight into the troubles of the human race." Twenty years later, as editor-in-chief of the Encyclopedia of Philosophy (published by Macmillan), Edwards wrote an article about Reich, comprising 11 pages as compared to the four devoted to Sigmund Freud. Edwards pointed out what is of interest to philosophers in Reich: his views concerning the origin of religious and metaphysical needs, the relation between the individual and society and the possibility of social progress, and, above all, the implications of his psychiatry for certain aspects of the mind-body problem. An abridged version of the article appeared in the Encyclopedia of Unbelief (ed. Gordon Stein, 1985).
Edwards omitted Reich's "orgone therapy" from the Encyclopedia article because, he said, "it is of no philosophical interest." But, in a BBC interview he said, "I concede that Reich had no real competence as a physicist... At the same time I am quite convinced that the orgone theory cannot be complete nonsense. For a number of years, largely out of curiosity, I sat in an orgone accumulator once a day."
One might wonder whether these irreligious men were seeking some way of fulfilling a religious impulse with orgone energy via the orgone accumulator.
Reich, who has been dubbed the "father of the sexual revolution," wrote in The Mass Psychology of Fascism:
Reich's scientific expertise was not as silly as has been widely claimed, according to James Strick. In 2015 Harvard University Press published Strick's Wilhelm Reich, Biologist, in which Strick writes that Reich's work in Oslo "represented the cutting edge of light microscopy and time-lapse micro-cinematography." Strick argues that the dominant narrative of Reich as a pseudoscientist is incorrect and that Reich's story is "much more complex and interesting."
Reich's updated book on fascism included a condemnation of Josef Stalin. Hence, he had few friends on the left when the federal government prosecuted him over sales of his orgone accumulator and "associated literature." Following two critical articles about him in The New Republic, headed by Stalin's former spy, Michael Straight, and Harper's in 1947, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration obtained an injunction against the interstate shipment of orgone accumulators and associated literature, believing they were dealing with a "fraud of the first magnitude." Charged with contempt in 1956 for having violated the injunction, Reich was sentenced to two years imprisonment, and that summer over six tons of his publications were burned by order of the court. He died in prison of heart failure just over a year later, days before he was due to apply for parole.
Much, but not all, information on this page is taken from two Wikipedia articles on Edwards and Reich.
For other footnoted information on Edwards, please see:
Footnote dh97
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-dh97.html
Footnote np54
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-np54.html
Footnote ds45
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-ds45.html
Footnote gk63
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-gk63.html
The appeal to individuation does not prove that disembodied mental existence is impossible. It only shows that we would not be able to justify believing in a plurality of disembodied minds as opposed to a single such mind; and [H.D.] Lewis rightly observes that it does not rule out the kind of Absolute Mind or Consciousness postulated by post-Hegelian idealists and certain Indian religions, or the "ocean of consciousness" of William James, [Erwin] Schroedinger, and [Arthur] Koestler... It is true that the ocean of consciousness theory has nothing to fear from individuation, but two other very serious problems arise in connection with it. In the first place it is not clear that we are dealing with a genuine theory. We are given no more than a vague picture – individual minds are said to merge into the Absolute Mind after death, just as drops of water merge into the ocean. We certainly understand what is meant by an ocean composed of water. We also understand what would be meant by an ocean composed of some other liquid – milk, for example, or champagne. But what is an ocean composed of "mental stuff," to use an expression common among philosophers writing during the last decade of the nineteenth century [and later]? And even if this difficulty is waived and we concede that statements about an ocean of consciousness possess some literal significance, there are strong reasons for supposing that no such ocean exists.(To learn more about those "strong reasons," please consult Edwards's anthology Immortality (Prometheus 1997). The above quotation is from his introduction to that anthology.)
This note may be of interest:
Of course, if one thinks of an individual as a stream, one sees that quite some while may elapse before the stream merges into a river and the river into the ocean. In other words, Edwards does not account for an in-between possibility. Such a possibility is given in the occasional testimonies of people who have experienced the merger of one "soul" with another. That is, such a person reports that, at least for short periods, there is an inability to distinguish the self – in the sense of who I am – from the other person (usually a lover). Many take such accounts to be poetic or metaphorical. But, if we regard the existence of spirits as just as plausible as the existence of matter, then such a possibility need not be regarded as a simple illusion.
On Edwards and his 'messiah'
Edwards saw Wilhelm Reich, a fellow Austrian Jew who had also escaped the Nazis, as a very important man, saying that on his arrival in New York in 1947, the "talk of the town" was Wilhelm Reich and that for years he and his friends regarded Reich as "something akin to a messiah."
"There was ... a widespread feeling that Reich had an original and penetrating insight into the troubles of the human race." Twenty years later, as editor-in-chief of the Encyclopedia of Philosophy (published by Macmillan), Edwards wrote an article about Reich, comprising 11 pages as compared to the four devoted to Sigmund Freud. Edwards pointed out what is of interest to philosophers in Reich: his views concerning the origin of religious and metaphysical needs, the relation between the individual and society and the possibility of social progress, and, above all, the implications of his psychiatry for certain aspects of the mind-body problem. An abridged version of the article appeared in the Encyclopedia of Unbelief (ed. Gordon Stein, 1985).
Edwards omitted Reich's "orgone therapy" from the Encyclopedia article because, he said, "it is of no philosophical interest." But, in a BBC interview he said, "I concede that Reich had no real competence as a physicist... At the same time I am quite convinced that the orgone theory cannot be complete nonsense. For a number of years, largely out of curiosity, I sat in an orgone accumulator once a day."
One might wonder whether these irreligious men were seeking some way of fulfilling a religious impulse with orgone energy via the orgone accumulator.
Reich, who has been dubbed the "father of the sexual revolution," wrote in The Mass Psychology of Fascism:
The basic religious idea in all patriarchal religions is the negation of the sexual needs. Only in very primitive religions were religiosity and sexuality identical. When social organization passed from matriarchy to patriarchy and class society, the unity of religious and sexual cult underwent a split; the religious cult became the antithesis of the sexual. With that, the cult of sexuality went out of existence. It was replaced by the brothel, pornography and backstairs-sexuality. It goes without saying that when sexual experiences ceased to be one with the religious cults, when, instead, they became antithetical to them, religious excitation assumed a new function: that of being a substitute for the lost sexual pleasure, now no longer affirmed by society. Only this contradiction inherent in religious excitation makes the strength and the tenacity of the religions understandable: the contradiction of its being at one and the same time antisexual and a substitute for sexuality.Shortly after he arrived in New York in 1939 Reich reported discovery of a biological or cosmic energy, an extension of Freud's idea of the libido. He called it "orgone energy" or "orgone radiation." His orgone accumulator supposedly cured cancer and effected other wonders.
Reich's scientific expertise was not as silly as has been widely claimed, according to James Strick. In 2015 Harvard University Press published Strick's Wilhelm Reich, Biologist, in which Strick writes that Reich's work in Oslo "represented the cutting edge of light microscopy and time-lapse micro-cinematography." Strick argues that the dominant narrative of Reich as a pseudoscientist is incorrect and that Reich's story is "much more complex and interesting."
Reich's updated book on fascism included a condemnation of Josef Stalin. Hence, he had few friends on the left when the federal government prosecuted him over sales of his orgone accumulator and "associated literature." Following two critical articles about him in The New Republic, headed by Stalin's former spy, Michael Straight, and Harper's in 1947, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration obtained an injunction against the interstate shipment of orgone accumulators and associated literature, believing they were dealing with a "fraud of the first magnitude." Charged with contempt in 1956 for having violated the injunction, Reich was sentenced to two years imprisonment, and that summer over six tons of his publications were burned by order of the court. He died in prison of heart failure just over a year later, days before he was due to apply for parole.
Much, but not all, information on this page is taken from two Wikipedia articles on Edwards and Reich.
For other footnoted information on Edwards, please see:
Footnote dh97
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-dh97.html
Footnote np54
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-np54.html
Footnote ds45
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-ds45.html
Footnote gk63
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-gk63.html
Footnote ds45
ds45. In his anthology of ancient and modern writers, Immortality (Prometheus 1997), Paul Edwards zeroes in on the mind/body problem. Edwards provides an excellent, lengthy introduction as well as a stimulating "Bibliographical Essay." Nothing from Ryle is excerpted nor, as far as I can tell, is Ryle even mentioned amid all the lively and wide-ranging discussion of the dualism issue. (We note that Edwards compiled Russell's late-career book, Why I am not a Christian (Allen and Unwin 1957) and that Russell and Ryle had had a furious row.)
In any case, for an excellent survey of the mind/body problem, see Edwards's Immortality.
For other footnoted information on Edwards, please see:
Footnote dh97
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-dh97.html
Footnote np54
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-np54.html
Footnote sf51
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-sf51.html
Footnote gk63
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-gk63.html
In any case, for an excellent survey of the mind/body problem, see Edwards's Immortality.
For other footnoted information on Edwards, please see:
Footnote dh97
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-dh97.html
Footnote np54
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-np54.html
Footnote sf51
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-sf51.html
Footnote gk63
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-gk63.html
Footnote np54
np54. Neitzsche, as quoted by Paul Edwards in Immortality (Prometheus 1997):
Similarly, Russell, in spite of all his labors, was in the end a bundle theorist. Edwards cites Russell's My Philosophical Development (Allen and Unwin 1959), urging that "Russell always thought of the spiritual substance as well as its material counterpart as 'grammatical illusions'." Further, said Russell,
The "bundle" issue, I suggest, in part arises from the nature of perception as a negative feedback system, a subject I discuss in my paper
Toward a signal model of perception
https://footnotestoplato1.blogspot.com/2020/05/toward-signal-model-of-perception_88.html
I do not in that paper attempt to address many of the philosophical issues raised by it.
For other footnoted information on Edwards, please see:
Footnote dh97
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-dh97.html
Footnote ds45
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-ds45.html
Footnote sf51
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-sf51.html
Footnote gk63
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-gk63.html
Behind the doing, acting, becoming, there is no agent, no "being." The "doer" has simply been added to the deed by the imagination -- the doing is everything. [Only the] snare of language ... blinds us to this fact.Well, does not that make the imagination an agent?
Similarly, Russell, in spite of all his labors, was in the end a bundle theorist. Edwards cites Russell's My Philosophical Development (Allen and Unwin 1959), urging that "Russell always thought of the spiritual substance as well as its material counterpart as 'grammatical illusions'." Further, said Russell,
The subject appears to be a logical fiction, like mathematical points and instants. It is introduced, not because observation requires it, but because it is linguistically convenient and apparently demanded by grammar.Edwards points out that Nietzsche and Russell sound very similar to the fifth-century Buddhist scholastic Buddha Ghosa, who opined:
For there is suffering, but none who suffer.(I don't know the circumstances of the translation of those words from Pali.)
Doing exists although there is no doer.
Extinction is but no extinguished person.
Although there is a path, there is no goer.
The "bundle" issue, I suggest, in part arises from the nature of perception as a negative feedback system, a subject I discuss in my paper
Toward a signal model of perception
https://footnotestoplato1.blogspot.com/2020/05/toward-signal-model-of-perception_88.html
I do not in that paper attempt to address many of the philosophical issues raised by it.
For other footnoted information on Edwards, please see:
Footnote dh97
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-dh97.html
Footnote ds45
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-ds45.html
Footnote sf51
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-sf51.html
Footnote gk63
https://thetaman.blogspot.com/2020/05/footnote-gk63.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
-
pHH34. In 1956, Russell lashed the plain language movement, which of course he knew to have been a legacy of Wittgenstein as championed by...
-
ub15. According to Johann Eduard Erdmann's interpretation, the redoubtable Aristotle fell short of resolving the dualism inherent in the...
-
ds45. In his anthology of ancient and modern writers, Immortality (Prometheus 1997), Paul Edwards zeroes in on the mind/body problem. Edwar...